Sunday 23 September 2012

FDI in retail: The Walmart experience in Punjab


Zirakpur: As the political storm over Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in multi-brand retail continues to rage, it is business as usual at a Bharti Walmart store in Zirakpur in Punjab. While most detractors of FDI would see red over the mention of Walmart - the American MNC is one of the few global retail giants that will now be able to set up shop in the country in partnership with an Indian entity - the store itself continues to do brisk business.

Spread over 53,000 square feet, the outlet sells more than 5,000 products every day, catering to hundreds of customers. It is primarily meant for retailers but also entertains small consumers - with most swearing by it as a one-stop shop for all their buys. 

"Here there are different brands and we get everything packed and it's fresh," says Piyush, a customer.



What's more, the franchise, working under the name Best Price, continues to thrive in the state. Having opened their first store in the state three years back, Bharti Walmart now boasts of five outlets in Punjab - Amritsar, Bathinda, Jalandhar, Ludhiana and Zirakpur. Catering to 5,000 customers daily, the franchises together have an annual estimated turnover of R
s.
 100 crore.

Farmers in the state, too, have given their thumbs up to this retail arrangement involving FDI. But they have a word of caution - they want the government to ensure that the big players do not end up dictating terms. 

"They will buy and sell at the price they like...but the good thing is that huge investment will bring development," says Mohinder Singh, a farmer.

Though proponents of organized retail claim that the new policy will enable farmers to market their produce better - global chains will buy directly from the farmer, thus shunting out middlemen - small retailers continue to be sceptical. Opponents of FDI have argued that the entry of MNCs will sound the death-knell for small traders. The trends in the last few years in the state may have reinforced these fears.

Four years ago, there were over a dozen retail outlets in Mohali like Subhiksha and 6-Ten, which have now shut shop. The stores faced stiff competition from the neighbourhood kirana stores in these years.

Now, as per industry estimates, big retail groups like Reliance Fresh, Big Bazaar, Easy Day have an eight to 10 percent retail share in Punjab.

But local kirana shops aren't particularly rattled by the presence of these big chains. 

"Initially customers will go there but later they will come back to us...We also offer home delivery and give other benefits to customers," says Raj Kumar, a kirana shop retailer. 

Some locals also agree with him. "Here we get personalised service...Also if we don't have money, we can buy now and pay later," Govind Singh, a customer, says.

While a few may have certain concerns, most do not view the entry of global chains as a threat or loss. The UPA government, which was plunged into a political crisis following its nod to 51% FDI in multi-brand retail, has been saying that fears over the policy are misplaced. While the debate over the controversial reform is likely to continue, the customers, as the model in Punjab suggests, aren't complaining.

US slams Pakistani minister's filmmaker bounty


Washington: The United States on Sunday condemned a Pakistani government minister's offer of a bounty to kill the maker of an anti-Islam film that has triggered violent protests around the Muslim world.
 
As demonstrators held more rallies against the film -- this time in Hong Kong, Turkey, Greece, Saudi Arabia, Iran and Bangladesh - even Pakistan's government distanced itself from the comments by its Railways Minister, Ghulam Ahmed Bilour.
 
On Saturday, Bilour offered a $100,000 "prize" for killing the filmmaker of "Innocence of Muslims" - an amateurish film made in the United States - and invited the Taliban and Al-Qaeda to take part in the "noble deed."



The State Department weighed in Sunday, with an official recalling that US President Barack Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton "have both said the video at the core of this is offensive, disgusting, and reprehensible.
 
The official added: "But that is no justification for violence and it is important for responsible leaders to stand up and speak out against violence."
 
"Therefore we find Mr. Bilour's announcement is inflammatory and inappropriate," the official said in a statement
 
In Pakistan, Prime Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf rejected the bounty offer.
 
"This is not government policy. We completely dissociate (ourselves) from this," a spokesman for the prime minister's office told AFP.
 
Fresh rallies were held across Pakistan on Sunday to condemn the film after violent nationwide protests on Friday left 21 people dead when police used tear gas and live rounds to fight back protesters.
 
More than 50 people have died in protests and attacks around the world linked to the low-budget film, which mocks Islam and the Prophet Mohammed, since the first demonstrations on September 11. Four US officials, including the ambassador to Libya, were killed in the Libyan city of Benghazi.
 
The publication on Wednesday of cartoons mocking the Prophet Mohammed in French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo has further stoked anger.
 
In France, an 18-year-old man who used Facebook to threaten the magazine's editors was charged Sunday with terrorism-related activity, a judicial source said.
 
Police arrested the teenager in the southern city of Toulon on Wednesday after he was reported by a person close to him who was concerned over his radicalism.
 
Police found several knives at his residence and said the man had threatened to go after those in charge of the weekly.
 
Meanwhile, an influential US lawmaker cast doubt over whether there was even an anti-American protest going on when the American ambassador to Libya was killed in an attack on the consulate in Benghazi.
 
The Obama administration initially said it believed extremists had not really planned the attack in Libya but rather had simply used a spontaneous protest over the anti-Islamic trailer as cover to mix in with the crowd and attack with weapons that included rocket-propelled grenades.
 
The White House for the first time Thursday described the assault as a "terrorist attack" and said it could have links to Al-Qaeda. But a Republican lawmaker cast doubt Sunday over whether the protests even happened.
 
"I have seen no information that shows that there was a protest going on as you have seen around any other embassy at the time," Mike Rogers, chairman of the House intelligence committee, told CNN's "State of the Union" program.
 
"The notion about the film... I think the administration was ill-advised to push down that road," he added.
 
Rogers said he believed it was a revenge attack timed to coincide with the 11th anniversary of 9/11 but that it wasn't clear if the militants had known Stevens was there or just got lucky.
 
"This had to be a pre-planned event. We know it was an act of terrorism. I think the administration has come to the conclusion it's an act of terrorism now," he said.
 
The State Department is under rising scrutiny about what appears to be inadequate security for Stevens and the consulate in Benghazi before the attack.


World T20: Harbhajan leads England's rout by 90 runs

Colombo: Harbhajan Singh grabbed 4-12 on his return after a year in the wilderness as India demolished defending champions England by 90 runs in the World Twenty20 on Sunday.


Rohit Sharma hit an unbeaten 55 off 33 balls as the new-look Indians scored 170-4 before England were shot out for their lowest T20 total of 80 in front of 20,000 spectators at the Premadasa stadium.

India rested seamer Zaheer Khan, spinner Ravichandran Ashwin and opener Virender Sehwag for the group A match that held only academic interest since both teams had already qualified for the Super Eights.

But it was a morale-boosting win for the 2007 champions ahead of the next round, as they dominated England from start to finish.

Harbhajan, 32, who had been out of favour with the selectors since August last year before being recalled for the World Twenty20, claimed a wicket off his second delivery when he came on in the sixth over.

When his spell finished in the 12th over, England had slumped to 60-8 and lost their ninth wicket also at the same total.

England were in danger of falling for the lowest ever total in Twenty20 internationals -- 67 by Kenya against Ireland in 2008 -- before the last-wicket pair of Steven Finn and Jade Dernbach prevented the humiliation.

But the total still fell below England's previous lowest score of 88 against the West Indies at the Oval last year.

Leg-spinner Piyush Chawla, who was also an unexpected selection for the match, claimed 2-13 as England faltered against both pace and spin.

Seamer Irfan Pathan bowled Alex Hales and trapped Luke Wright leg-before in his first two overs to reduce England to 18-2.

Wickets fell at regular intervals and the innings ended in the 15th over to complete a dominant win for India.

Other notable contributions for India came from Gautam Gambhir, who made 45, and Virat Kohli, who smashed 40 off 32 balls.

Makeshift opener Pathan fell for eight before the in-form Kohli hit six boundaries during a second-wicket stand of 57 with Gambhir.

Sharma and skipper Mahendra Singh Dhoni took 38 runs in the last three overs to lift India past the 150-run mark.

England made one change from the team that beat Afghanistan, dropping left-arm spinner Samit Patel to play seamer Tim Bresnan.

Cabinet may consider hike in dearness allowance of Central Govt employees in a meeting today


New Delhi: The Union Cabinet is expected to meet this evening to consider a 7 per cent hike in the Dearness Allowance (DA) of Central government employees.


Once approved, it will benefit over 52 lakh government employees.



The Cabinet will also take a decision on computerisation of the Public Distribution System (PDS). A Food Ministry proposal seeks to digitise ration cards and fully computerise the PDS network especially at the back-end.



Also, a bailout package for state power distribution companies is on the cards. The Cabinet is likely to consider a proposal for debt recasting of power distribution companies.


The meetings of the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) and Cabinet Committee on Infrastructure (CCI), scheduled for Friday, were postponed apparently in view of the rapid political developments in the aftermath of the government's decision to hike diesel prices and operationalise its earlier move to allow Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in multi- brand retail.



The hike in dearness allowance will be effective from July 1, 2012, and the employees would be entitled to arrears from that date.



The additional burden on exchequer on account of increase in DA would be around R
s.
 5,000 crore for the eight-month period between July, 2012 and February, 2013. It will be R
s.
 7,400 crore for the full financial year.



The government had last increased DA in March this year from 58 per cent to 65 per cent, which was effective from January 1, 2012. It will now be increased to 72 per cent.



The government periodically hikes the DA, which is linked to consumer price index for industrial workers. The consumer price index (CPI) based on movement in retail prices, soared to 10.03 per cent in August, from 9.86 per cent in July.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cabinet-may-consider-hike-in-dearness-allowance-of-central-govt-employees-in-a-meeting-today-271232?pfrom=home-otherstories

Anna Hazare will be back with us in three-four months, says Arvind Kejriwal


New Delhi: Less than a week after splitting with Anna Hazare, anti-graft activist Arvind Kejriwal today said that the Gandhian will be back with him in another "three-four months" if he can work honestly in politics. 

"He will come back in three-four months once he sees our honest and dedicated work," Mr Kejriwal said today at Jantar Mantar, where he led a protest against hike in power tariffs, alleging that the Delhi government and private discoms were out to loot people.
 
"Everybody's been saying Anna's left us. Anna has not left us, he's in our hearts. He just thinks politics is dirty. We think there's no option but to enter and do a cleanup. We have immense respect for Anna," Mr Kejriwal said.



"I've been forced to enter politics. I'm not doing it out of choice," he added.

Earlier this week, Anna had asked the Kejriwal-led group not to use his name or poster during its campaign as a political group. Anna, 75, and his supporters, including Kiran Bedi, parted ways with the Kejriwal-led group on September 19 over the anti-graft activists deciding to launch a political party.

Mr Kejriwal and his group gathered at Jantar Mantar this afternoon and shouted slogans against Congress-led Delhi government and private discoms. They also burnt electricity bills.

The protest, which is being seen as a prelude to an entry into politics formally, demonstrated keenness of the Kejriwal-led group to fight Delhi Assembly elections slated next year as it targeted Sheila Dikshit's Congress government in the national capital.

However, today's protest did not attract the kind of response which earlier protests by India Against Corruption used to witness; around a 1000-odd people turned up.

Besides Mr Kejriwal, other prominent activists who attended today's protest were Prashant Bhushan, Manish Sisodia, Kumar Vishwas and Sanjay Singh.



Landslides, heavy rains claim 27 lives in Sikkim, Assam


Gangtok/Guwahati: Landslides triggered by heavy rains claimed 27 lives, including those of Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) and Border Roads Organisation (BRO) personnel in Sikkim, even as flood situation in Assam and Arunachal Pradesh deteriorated with vast areas reeling under its impact.

Official sources on Sunday said in Gangtok that at least 21 bodies, including those of the ITBP and the BRO personnel, were found while eight persons were missing following flash floods and landslides in remote areas of North Sikkim.

Army and IAF personnel have launched rescue operations in full swing in the badly affected areas. 



The dead include four from the ITBP, two of their family members, and 12 junior officers from the BRO. Other victims were casual labourers, they said. Most of the casualties were reported from Rangma range.

Landslides were caused by heavy rains since September 19, Deputy Commissioner North district T W Khangsherpa said, adding there were about nine landslides blocking the main road between Chungthang and Mangan in the district.

Yesterday, another landslide occurred at an area about a kilometre from Mangan, the district headquarter town of North Sikkim, blocking NH 31-A and leaving the northern side of the Himalayan state cut off.

In Assam, flood situation deteriorated with 15 districts reeling under its impact, as large parts of Dibru-Saikhowa and Kaziranga National Parks and Pobitora Wildlife Sanctuary submerged. Five deaths have been reported, official sources said in Guwahati.

The surging waters of the swollen rain-fed Brahmaputra and its tributaries overran fresh areas affecting an estimated five lakh people in Dibrugarh, Sonitpur, Tinsukia, Golaghat, Morigaon, Dhemaji, Kamrup (Rural), Lakhimpur, Baksa, Barpeta, Jorhat, Nalbari, Sibsagar and Udalguri districts.

Troops of the Tezpur-headquartered Gajraj Corps swung into action in flood-hit Sonitpur district of central Assam and rescued around 4000 civilians in the past four-five days. The IAF also dropped 2.4 tonnes of relief material. 

In Sonitpur district, the Army and National Disaster Relief Force (NDRF) were assisting the district administration in rescue and relief operations, pressing into service 10 special boats where road communication has been snapped by the deluge, district Deputy Commissioner Tapan Chandra Sarma.

Tinsukia district administration has airlifted 100 marooned people in waterlogged Sadiya subdivision's Paanch Mile area and Army helicopters were airdropping food items there.

In the third wave of floods during the current year, two persons, including a woman, were washed away in Dibrugarh district yesterday, one person drowned in Demow river in Dhemaji district and two others in Tinsukia district's Dhola area on September 13.

Incessant rains in Arunachal Pradesh, Bhutan foothills and in Assam for the last 15 days, have caused the Brahmaputra and its tributaries to rise above the danger level in most places and breach river dykes, embankments and overflow into human habitats and farm land.

Over two lakh people have been affected in the fresh wave of floods in five districts of Arunachal Pradesh with majority of the rivers and tributaries flowing over the danger mark yesterday, official sources said in Itanagar. One person died due to the floods in the state.

At least 39 marooned people, including 12 children, who were stranded between the branches of Lohit river since four days were rescued by Indian Air Force last evening, Lohit Deputy Commissioner R K Sharma said.

Meanwhile, UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi has assured Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Nabam Tuki that the Centre would soon send a team to take stock of the damage caused by floods in the state.

Mrs Gandhi, during a meeting with the chief minister on Saturday, said the Centre was aware of the worsening flood situation in Arunachal and assured all possible help to repair damage caused by sudden floods.


FDI in retail: LK Advani slams Prime Minister for laying 'red carpet' for Walmart


New Delhi: Slamming Prime Minister Manmohan Singh over the issue of allowing FDI in multi-brand retail, BJP leader LK Advani today said the red carpet was being rolled out for Walmart when it faced protests even in the US and New York City "shut Walmart out".

In his latest blog, he referred to the reported unrest brewing against US' largest retailer Walmart in various American cities at a time when the government here was "rolling out the red carpet" for it. He also said that the BJP had opposed the measure when NDA was in power.

Quoting an article of author and financial expert S Gurumurthy, he said that on September 14, when the Prime Minister rolled out the red carpet for Walmart, the same day "New York City shut Walmart out".


He also referred to a web-based newspaper which carried a story on how Walmart displaced nearby small businesses the day FDI in retail was notified in India last week.

"Weeks ago, on June 30, over 10,000 people, shouting Walmart = Poverty, marched through Los Angeles against Walmart stores," Mr Advani said quoting Mr Gurumurthy.

He also quoted a New York Times report on how Mexico has become the second largest country for Walmart after USA in terms of number of stores.

"According to a New York Times report, this has been achieved by the retail giant's Mexico arm by dishing out generous payouts to aid its mammoth growth," he said.

Mr Advani said that shortly after the Times published its investigation in April, 2012, Walmart confirmed that it had launched an investigation into the "allegations of bribery at Walmart de Mexico".

He said "leading" Congress leader PR Dasmunshi in December 2002 had said bureaucrats were being pressurised by multi-national retailers even when a group of ministers and a task force of the Planning Commission on employment had rejected FDI in retail.

"Mr Dasmunshi had said that through bureaucrats multi-national retailers are continuously putting pressure on the government to take this anti-national decision of allowing foreign direct investment in retail trade," Mr Advani said.

He said when Mr Dashmunshi raised this issue in Parliament, Commerce and Industry Minister Arun Shourie immediately stood up and said that as per the existing policy since 1997 foreign direct investment in retail trade is not permitted.